CACA Tumor Markers Committee · 2024 · Expert Consensus

Tumor DNA Methylation Biomarkers: Detection & Clinical Application — Consensus 2024

肿瘤 DNA 甲基化标志物检测及临床应用专家共识(2024 版)
10 expert statements (mostly strong) · exfoliated-cell + blood dual pathways approved · full-course application: screening → diagnosis → companion → MRD → recurrence
Ding C, Guo W, Mao R, Nian W, Xiang T, Yu J, Yang Z, Zhang H — CACA Tumor Markers Committee
Chin J Cancer Prev Treat 2024;16(2):129–142 · OCEBM evidence levels · international guideline registry
10
expert statements (strong)
Exfoliated
cervical · bladder · CRC · lung approved
Blood
CRC · gastric · lung · liver approved
Full-course
screening → MRD → recurrence

1Background & Framework

  • Scope: definition · clinical significance · testing specs · data processing · full-course application.
  • Method: OCEBM evidence grading; expert vote — >90% strong, 70–90% recommend.
  • Platforms: PCR (simple) · nucleic-acid mass spec (mid-throughput) · NGS (high-throughput, complex, costly).

2Testing Standards

Minimize
transport time · early separation
No heparin
avoid hemolysis
2-step
centrifugation for cfDNA
  • Sample: no freeze of RBC blood before separation; preservative solution for stool.
  • Quality: concentration · purity · integrity per sample type; fragment profile to exclude gDNA contamination.
  • Conversion: bisulfite or enzymatic, fit specimen & application.
  • Platform choice: balance marker number · scenario · conditions (PCR/mass-spec/NGS).
PCR
simple · few markers
Mass spec
mid-throughput · mid-cost
NGS
high-throughput · complex
Bisulfite
conversion
Enzymatic
conversion
PCR/MS/NGS
platforms
Conc.
quality metric
Purity
quality metric
Integrity
quality metric
  • Reproducibility: essential before clinical adoption of any methylation assay.
  • Purpose-fit: screening, diagnosis, companion & MRD each shape assay design.
  • Data pipeline: raw → QC → methylation levels → clinical interpretation.
  • Blood for cfDNA: sufficient volume, two-step centrifugation, no freeze before separation.
  • Data QC: platform-dependent thresholds; reproducibility & stability required.
  • Validation: each specimen type has its own quality acceptance criteria.
  • Technology watch: follow latest conversion & platform advances.
Consensus: sampling, extraction/conversion & platform selection all standardized (strong recommendations); assay choice balances markers, scenario & lab conditions.

3Product Use Scenarios — Cervical & Endometrial

PAX1 / JAM3 (CISCER)
Cervical brushing methylation — hrHPV(+) triage, cytology-free stratification; recommended by consensus.
宫颈癌
CDO1 / CELF4 (CISENDO)
Cervical/uterine brushing methylation — endometrial cancer detection & screening; recommended by consensus.
子宫内膜癌
Cervical cancer screening pathway (4)
hrHPV(+) high-risk / cytology-abnormal stratification · TZ3 & potential adenocarcinoma risk · post-treatment monitoring · exit-screening assessment.
Endometrial cancer screening pathway (3)
imaging + methylation co-screening · genital bleeding stratified management · high-risk population screening.

4Recommended Flowchart — Cervical Cancer Methylation (Fig 1)

Recommended cervical cancer methylation screening flowchart
Fig 1 · Suggested workflow for cervical cancer DNA methylation screening
Entry: HPV(+) high-risk or cytology-abnormal women → methylation triage → colposcopy decision; extended: TZ3/adenocarcinoma risk, post-treatment monitoring & exit assessment.
4
cervical pathways
3
endometrial pathways
2
endorsed dual-gene kits
  • PCDHGB7: SJTU IHPH — specificity superior to cytology in non-16/18 hrHPV+ triage.
  • PAX1 methylation: 2 large Chinese studies — hrHPV+ stratified management.
  • CDO1/CELF4: endometrial Se/Sp validated; BHLHE22/CDO1/HAND2 Se 86.0%.
  • Approved exfoliated kits: cervical · bladder · CRC · lung (NMPA).
  • Endometrial PCDHGB7: early Se 85.71%/Sp 80.60% — CE certified.
  • Self-sampling: tampon samples match physician collection.
Fig 1 + pathways anchor recommended usage — endorses PAX1/JAM3 (cervical) & CDO1/CELF4 (endometrial).
Clinical Significance